-
No. 1 on my wishlist is more wiki-like functionality for the Pages module, including:
- Ability to revert to previous version of a Page in addition to just viewing previous versions.
- MediaWiki-style discussion pages for each Page.
- Ability to compare differences between revisions of a Page.
- Ability for individuals to have pages as well as groups.
- Markdown support.As you can imagine, I’m using Pages quite a lot on my site and am quickly realizing its limitations. However, the fine-grained access controls are still worth sacrificing some advanced wiki features for. I may end up coding some of this functionality myself via plugins.
-
Here is my wishlist.
http://kempwire.com/elgg/elgg-development-wishlist.html
My number one request is for Elgg to implement Search Engine Optimization. At the least, Elgg needs unique title tags for pages, blog posts and files. This is a basic principle that has been overlooked.
My second request is for an 0.9-1.x upgrade path. Is that what they mean by “OpenDD import and export – Completed?”
-
Well, I’m back. After taking some time to compare Buddypress with Elgg, I’m moving forward with Elgg. Now it’s just a matter of remembering everything I tried to figure out before that it would not do.
-
Agreed – two different animals that both have great benefits and promise. Elgg to me is a more intimate, social experience like facebook. Buddypress is more like open and busy like MySpace.
-
Steve,
I agree on most points you make. I’ve tried them both, and decided to go for Elgg for a project I’m working on. However, I think Elgg can learn a few things already implemented in Buddypress:- private messaging to more than one user at a time (I don’t see this in the roadmap, and no one replied to me about this when I submitted a comment on this in the elgg users google group)
- make it easy to customize the homepage with widgets
I think Elgg has lots of potential, but it certainly still has a long way to go
Comments are now closed.


10 comments