I recently came across CommentPress. It’s a WordPress plugin that allows readers to comment on a post paragraph by paragraph. CommentPress looks like a very promising collaboration tool. CommentPress is on the cusp of a major upgrade from version 1.4.1 to 2.0. We will look at features in the current version, and preview Version 2.0.
Currently, CommentPress is a WP theme. Install it and activate it.
The resultant main page includes a table of contents on the left side, a “page” that you can customize in the center, and some widgets on the right. The meat of this comes when you clink a link to one of the posts.
Each paragraph has a “speech bubble” to the right of it. Click on that and you can view all the other comments on that paragraph. Comments can even be threaded. Whether or not there are comments already, there is a text field for entering comments.
As it stands, CommentPress works well. Yet the developers plan on giving it even greater flexibility with version 2.0 due out in a couple weeks. I had trouble with the beta on my server, so I can only write about what I have seen and read on their site.
Rather than just a theme, the new version will include 3 plugins and a theme that can work independently so you only use the components you need. You will be able to use it with most WordPress themes. The comment box can be dragged and dropped to any location on the page. There are also enhancements that improve CommentPress’s ability to work with changed text in the posts. I also understand that it will be more flexible in working with other widgets and plugins.
CommentPress’s potential in education and in other areas is great. The ability to annotate and critique text paragraph by paragraph make it much easier to focus a response to a given segment of text. It would work well for peer editing of student writing. Teachers could post a segment of text for students to read allowing them to respond to the text and other comments. I have installed CommentPress to facilitate discussion of our school’s web publishing policy.
I look forward to working with a new version of CommentPress, but I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend it as it is today. As a bonus, the current version works with WPMU, and I hope the newer version will as well.
Related Posts
Tags: collaboration, commentpress, comments, wordpress, WPMU
-
Nice.
-
CommentPress is really slick…I posted a comment-able version of my dissertation using it at http://jasonrhode.com/publications/dissertation
-
Funny you should say that because my first thought was that it would be such a great way to get feedback on a dissertation.
I look forward to the next version’s ability to deal with edits to the post text. It has me wondering if it could work with a WP wiki plugin that I am about to review. That would be awesome!
-
-
Steve,
Have you come across Marginalia Web annotation, a javascript package at http://www.geof.net/code/annotation/ ? It seems to me that there may be an overlap with Comment Press.And on a separate subject, do you know of a good forum where all the Social Networking systems (Elgg, BuddyPress, etc) are discussed from the pedagogical point of view?
-
Mark–
Great to hear from you again. I checked out Marginalia and I really liked the ability to highlight specific text to comment on. I’m going to look into it more.
I can’t think of a forum that is specifically focused on pedagogy and open source social networking systems. I would certainly would welcome such.
Reply
Creative Commons License
Openedweb by Stephen J. O’Connor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
5 comments
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link: http://openedweb.com/blog/2009/02/24/commentpress/trackback/